Best Pizza

27 restaurants ranked by average score across 35 visits

All lists

John's of Bleeker

New York, NY 1 visit last Nov 2022

Go-to dish Piccante Pie

"w/ Amy. Very Good: Piccante Pie" -- from that visit

8.0 avg

Monkey's Ink'd Pizza

Austin, TX 1 visit last Aug 2022

8.0 #3

Via 313

Austin, TX 1 visit last Apr 2021

8.0 #4

Jet's Pizza

Austin, TX 1 visit last Aug 2022

7.5 #5

Bufalina

Austin, TX 5 visits last Jan 2024

7.3 #6

The Backspace

Austin, TX 3 visits last Apr 2023

7.0 #7

Young Joni

Minneapolis, MN 2 visits last Apr 2024

7.0 #8

Como's Pizza

Detroit, MI 1 visit last Sep 2022

7.0 #9

Home Slice Pizza

Austin, TX 1 visit last Feb 2021

7.0 #10

Pedroso

Austin, TX 1 visit last Apr 2021

7.0 #11

Yia Yias

Lincoln, NE 1 visit last Oct 2023

7.0 #12

Scarr's Pizza

New York, NY 1 visit last Nov 2022

6.5 #13

Buddy's

Detroit, MI 1 visit last Sep 2022

6.0 #14

La Volta Pizza Club

Austin, TX 1 visit last Jun 2025

6.0 #15

Serious Pie

Seattle, WA 1 visit last Nov 2025

6.0 #16

Sunset Squares Slice Shop

San Francisco, CA 1 visit last Feb 2022

6.0 #17

The Masonry

Seattle, WA 1 visit last Apr 2026

6.0 #18

Windy City Pie

Seattle, WA 1 visit last Nov 2025

6.0 #19

Sauce

New York, NY 1 visit last Nov 2022

5.5 #20

Rocco's

Seattle, WA 2 visits last May 2026

5.0 #21

Bufalina Sicilian

Austin, TX 1 visit last May 2021

5.0 #22

Ian's Pizza

Denver, CO 1 visit last May 2021

5.0 #23

Little Caesars

Mexico City 1 visit last May 2023

5.0 #24

Roosevelt Pizzeria

San Diego, CA 1 visit last Nov 2021

5.0 #25

Dough Boys

Austin, TX 1 visit last Feb 2022

4.0 #26

Pinthouse Pizza (Ben White)

Austin, TX 1 visit last Nov 2022

4.0 #27

Slice Works

Denver, CO 1 visit last May 2021

4.0

Pizza elsewhere