Carrigan Chicken Company logo
Carrigan Chicken Company

Best Pizza in New York

3 restaurants · ranked by average score across 3 visits

See Pizza in every city → See everything in New York →
#1
John's of Bleeker
New York, NY · 1 visit · last Nov 2022
Go-to dish → Piccante Pie
"w/ Amy. Very Good: Piccante Pie" — from that visit
8.0 avg
#2
Scarr's Pizza
New York, NY · 1 visit · last Nov 2022
6.5 #3
Sauce
New York, NY · 1 visit · last Nov 2022
5.5

Pizza elsewhere

Other best-of in New York

How this list is built. Restaurants are ranked by their average score across every logged visit. Ties break on visit count, then alphabetical. Must be tagged with "Pizza" and located in New York. Updated automatically with every new visit.
shape
palette